The record
Laws.
What the rulings decide, and what they do not.
The following record traces the transition from ancient legal disputes concerning ritual and lethal emergency to the modern political claim that elective abortion is a value.
1
One shelf
There is no single Jewish ruling on abortion. The pages decide different questions. A tort. A lethal birth. Ritual impurity. The execution of a woman already condemned. Then a split, a thousand years later, over whether the child in the womb is not yet a life or is a pursuer of its mother. Then another split, in the last century, over how far that permission goes.
Open a line. The decision is there, and the text it comes from is linked. A modern campaign is marked as a campaign. We do not rename a ruling as a ceremony, and we do not give this page a number. The eight questions are for a story. This page is a shelf of rulings.
2
The rulings
1A fine, not a capital chargeExodus 21:22–25
Two men fight. A pregnant woman is struck. Her offspring comes out. If there is no further harm, the man pays a fine the husband demands and the court sets. If there is further harm, the law moves to life for life.
In the rabbinic reading, the fine is for the offspring and the capital clause is for harm to the woman. This is a tort about an accidental blow. It is not a statute that authorizes ending a pregnancy.
2The Greek Bible changes the verseSeptuagint, Exodus 21:22–23
The Hebrew does not divide an unformed child from a formed one. The Greek translation does. An imperfectly formed child draws a fine. A perfectly formed child draws life for life.
Christian law inherited the Greek. Jewish law inherited the Hebrew. The two traditions are not reading the same sentence. That is a fact about a translation. It is not a license, and it is not a plot.
3Only a birth that is killing herMishnah Oholot 7:6, about 200 CE
If a woman is in hard labor, they cut the child up in her womb and bring it out limb by limb, because her life comes before its life. Once most of the child has come out, they do not touch it, because one life is not set aside for another.
This is the ruling every later opinion quotes. It permits killing the child to save the mother during a birth that is already killing her. It forbids touching the child once the head, or most of the body, has emerged, even if the mother dies. It does not speak to a healthy pregnancy.
4Forty days, and a question of impurityMishnah Niddah 3:7
If she miscarries on the fortieth day, she need not treat it as a birth for ritual impurity. On the forty-first, she counts the impurity of a birth. Rabbi Ishmael puts a male at forty-one days and a female at eighty-one. The Sages say both are complete on the forty-first.
The calendar is the Greek medical one: a male formed at forty days, a female later. The question is whether the mother is ritually impure. The mishnah does not say the embryo may be destroyed.
5Merely waterBabylonian Talmud, Yevamot 69b
Rav Hisda says that until forty days the embryo is merely water. The case is a priest’s daughter and whether she may still eat terumah, food set aside for priests. Until forty days, a pregnancy does not change that status.
It is a rule about sacred food. It is not a permission to abort.
6A woman already condemnedMishnah Arakhin 1:4 and Babylonian Talmud, Arakhin 7a
A pregnant woman condemned to death is not spared until she gives birth. If she is already on the birth stool, they wait. The Gemara asks why the rule was needed. The answer it rejects is that the child might be the husband’s property, because Exodus 21:22 makes the loss a fine paid to him. The court will not delay a capital sentence to save that interest. The line “it is her body” is the Gemara’s question, not a celebration.
Samuel, reported by Rabbi Judah, adds a procedure: strike her abdomen so the child dies first, to spare her corpse the disgrace of a birth after death. The woman is already sentenced. The text states no concern for the child. It is not a rule for a woman who is not condemned.
7Not yet a lifeRashi on Sanhedrin 72b
Rashi explains the birth ruling. While the child is in the womb it is not a nefesh, a life in the full legal sense, so the mother’s life comes first.
He is explaining Oholot. He is not writing a permission for a pregnancy that does not threaten her. Later authorities who weigh grave suffering, short of death, are building on this explanation. The explanation itself is the birth case.
8A pursuer, and then a personMaimonides, Mishneh Torah, Murderer and the Preservation of Life 1:9
If a birth is killing her, the child may be destroyed with a drug or a knife, because it is like a rodef, a pursuer who is trying to kill her. Once the head has emerged, it is not touched. One life is not pushed aside for another. Maimonides says this is the nature of the world.
He did not need the word pursuer if the child were simply nothing. By using it, he ties the permission to a threat against the mother. On this reading, abortion is otherwise forbidden. The permission is the emergency. It is not a choice.
9No death penalty is not the same as permissionBabylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 57b
The Talmud reads Genesis 9:6, for the children of Noah, as covering the blood of a man within a man: a child in the womb. A Noahide who kills a fetus is treated as liable. A Jewish court does not execute a Jew for the same act.
That is a difference in criminal category. It is not a rule that one people may abort and another may not. The strict authorities of the last century still forbid the act to a Jew.
10Tantamount to murderMoshe Feinstein, Igrot Moshe, Choshen Mishpat 2:69
Feinstein holds that killing a fetus is forbidden as murder, for a Jew as for a Noahide, even though a Jewish court does not put the killer to death. Abortion is permitted only when the mother will otherwise die. Where that danger is real, it is not a choice. It is what the law requires. Where it is not, it is forbidden.
He is not the only strict voice, and the strict voices do not use one word. Shmuel Wosner rejects Feinstein’s classification of the act as murder, and still permits it only when the mother’s life may be at risk. Elective abortion is outside both of those lines.
11Grave harm, still not electiveEliezer Waldenberg, Tzitz Eliezer 9:51
Waldenberg permits an abortion to save the mother’s life without hesitation. He also leaves room where her health is poor and the abortion is to cure her or to relieve great pain, even if she is not about to die, and in some cases of a seriously impaired child, preferably early.
He treats the child, on this line, more as part of the mother than as an independent life, so the act is closer to an injury than to murder. He does not treat a healthy pregnancy as optional. The lenient construction and the strict one use the same old pages and do not reach the same door.
The campaign12A campaign is not a clauseNational Council of Jewish Women, 2020
On 29 June 2020 the National Council of Jewish Women, with Sheila Katz and Danya Ruttenberg, wrote that the fetus is not regarded as a person, that abortion access is a fundamental Jewish issue, and that this is not just a matter of Jewish law, but of Jewish values. The Council’s toolkit, still on its site, tells a reader to send it to a lawmaker and let them know abortion is a Jewish value. Reform, Conservative, and Reconstructionist bodies have moved in the same direction: the woman’s judgment is treated as decisive.
That is an organization’s public argument. It is not a mishnah, and it is not Maimonides. Orthodox decisors contest it, and they say so from the rulings above. A reader can hold the campaign in one hand and Oholot in the other. They are not the same kind of sentence.
Abortion and Jewish Values Toolkit
That page, saved 30 October 2026
3
What the shelf will not do
The classical pages do not authorize elective abortion. Feinstein calls it murder unless the mother will otherwise die. Waldenberg is wider, and he still does not treat a healthy pregnancy as a choice. The National Council of Jewish Women says access is a Jewish value. That sentence is theirs. It is dated. It can be read. It cannot be moved backward into the Mishnah.
A household that wants a judgment has the texts. We will not write a charge the texts do not contain.






























