The record
The account.
One person. One year. Did they pay in more than they used?
Denmark’s Finance Ministry added it up for 2019. Taxes in. Health, school, care, and cash benefits out. A plus means the person paid in more. A minus means they used more.
+52,000 krAn immigrant from Western countries paid in more than they used.About 7,800 dollars. The ministry published kroner.
−74,000 krAn immigrant from the Middle East, North Africa, Pakistan, or Turkey used more than they paid in.About 11,000 dollars. Same year, same rule.
The same rule, for each group
An immigrant from Western countries
Paid in 52,000 kroner more
A person of Danish origin
Paid in 22,000 kroner more
An immigrant from other countries outside the West
Paid in 14,000 kroner more
An immigrant from the Middle East, North Africa, Pakistan, or Turkey
Used 74,000 kroner more
A child of that last group, born in Denmark
Used 109,000 kroner more
Per person, 2019. Table 2.1 of the revised September 2023 edition.
The whole country that year
- People of Danish origin: the public accounts gained 112 billion kroner.
- Western immigrants and their children: a gain of 11 billion.
- Immigrants from the Middle East, North Africa, Pakistan, and Turkey, and their children: a loss of 24 billion.
- Every immigrant and every child of an immigrant: a loss of 16 billion.
In 2014 that last loss was 34 billion, in 2019 prices. By 2019 it was 16 billion. The cost got smaller. It stayed a cost.
Age does not explain the gap
Their children are young, and a child uses school and care in every group. The ministry asked what the averages would be if each group had the same ages as people of Danish origin.
- Immigrants from the Middle East, North Africa, Pakistan, and Turkey go from using 74,000 kroner more to using 111,000 more. Age does not explain it.
- Their children, born in Denmark, go from using 109,000 more to using 52,000 more. Age explains part of it.
- Children of Western immigrants go from a cost to a gain, about 20,000 kroner paid in. Their cost was age.
Not every person
Among immigrants from those countries, about one in four paid in more than 50,000 kroner. About one in three used more than 150,000. The average is the group. It is not every person in it.
What this is not
This is Denmark in 2019, not the United States. It counts residents, including children born there. It does not count wages, crime, or whether someone crossed a border without papers. The list of countries is Syria, Kuwait, Libya, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon, Somalia, Iraq, Qatar, Sudan, Bahrain, Djibouti, Jordan, Algeria, the United Arab Emirates, Tunisia, Egypt, Morocco, Iran, Yemen, Mauritania, Oman, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Turkey.
Questions
Were immigrants a net cost in this count?
All immigrants together were a small net gain in 2019: about 5,000 kroner a person, and about 3 billion kroner in total. Immigrants and their children together were a net cost of about 16 billion. The average hides the split.
What did the ministry find for MENAPT immigrants?
Immigrants from the MENAPT countries averaged a net cost of 74,000 kroner a person in 2019. With their children, the group cost about 24 billion kroner. MENAPT is the ministry’s list: the Middle East, North Africa, Pakistan, and Turkey.
What did Western immigrants contribute?
Western immigrants averaged a net gain of 52,000 kroner a person. Western immigrants and their children together contributed about 11 billion kroner.
Is the deficit only because the group is young?
No for MENAPT immigrants. Give them the same ages as people of Danish origin, and the average goes from about 74,000 kroner under to about 111,000 under. Age does not create that deficit. It hides part of it. For Western descendants the raw deficit is age: the same correction turns their average from a cost into a gain.
Is this the United States?
No. The count is Denmark’s tax and benefit system in 2019. The ministry has not published a later year. A kroner figure does not transfer to a state budget.
The publication is Økonomisk Analyse: Indvandreres nettobidrag til de offentlige finanser i 2019, revised September 2023. The tables on this page are read from the ministry’s spreadsheet of figures. What a birth year holds is on Lost posterity. What the rulings decide about a child is on Laws.






























